undamentalytics Newsletter

Baldwin Insurance Group vs Erie Indemnity

Erie Indemnity is the larger business, with $4.07bn of revenue in fiscal 2025 against $1.50bn for Baldwin Insurance Group (2.7 times as much). Baldwin Insurance Group grew faster (8.3% against 7.2%). Erie Indemnity kept more of each dollar of sales as profit: a net margin of 13.8% against -2.2%.

Latest fiscal yearBaldwin Insurance GroupBWIN, 2025Erie IndemnityERIE, 2025
Revenue $1.50bn $4.07bn
Revenue growth 8.3% 7.2%
Net income −$33.8m $559m
Operating margin — 17.6%
Net margin -2.2% 13.8%
Return on equity -5.7% 26.2%
Free cash flow −$68.9m $571m
Cash $124m $346m
Total debt $1.60bn $0
Debt to equity — 0.0%
Dividend per share — —
Dividend yield — 2.1%
Share buybacks — —
Employees 5,000 6,667
Market value $2.96bn $12.65bn
Price vs our value range — Within our value range
Moat score — —
Insider trades, 12 months 2 buys, 12 sales 3 buys, 1 sales

Each figure is from the company's latest annual report and links to the page it comes from. Fiscal years can end on different dates. Market value and the value verdict use the delayed price shown on the stock pages. Not a recommendation.

Go deeper

Figures from each company's latest annual report filed with the SEC (10-K or 20-F), as reported, with the fiscal year shown. Not investment advice. How we read filings: methodology.